Reviews

Abbey Drevline Avatar

Timeless, elegant, and personable. The Diamond Reserve took my lifetime vision of my engagement ring and turned my dream into a reality. Not a day goes by that I don’t look at my ring and admire every detail that was put into it. I also had such a great experience with Erin and picking out our wedding bands!! The whole team is amazing and I highly recommended!

Abbey Drevline 11/23/2021
Sarah Maslo Avatar

Working with the Diamond Reserve for both my engagement ring and wedding band was a fantastic decision. I wanted a small, simple, lab-grown gemstone ring and they were so respectful of that wish. They designed a set that really matches my personality; I love both my engagement ring and wedding band. Their work is beautiful, and I'd absolutely recommend them to anyone searching for an engagement ring.

Sarah Maslo 11/21/2021
Ashley Kiss Avatar

Erin was such a pleasure to work with while my now fiancé and I designed my engagement ring! Being new to the diamond industry ourselves, Erin educated us on diamonds on all aspects. Her knowledge and expertise was very helpful throughout the entire experience. She was not pushy or impatient with us as we took our time, and as life through us some curveballs during the process. The turnaround time on the ring was very quick too! We will absolutely be working with Erin when we start to design my wedding band. I highly recommend the Diamond Reserve!

Ashley Kiss 10/28/2021
Alexandra Hoffman Avatar

We loved working with Erin on designing my engagement ring, so we came back to design our wedding bands with her too! Erin was always so responsive and was able to meet with us during the weekday evenings which was so convenient. Their turnaround times are quick, and the prices for custom rings were lower than what we saw at other jewelry stores for stock settings and wedding bands. Highly, highly recommend!!

Alexandra Hoffman 10/18/2021
Taylor and Brian Shanfeld Avatar

Erin K. @ Diamond Reserve is fantastic.
Super responsive, helpful… she and her team design BEAUTIFUL pieces…. my (now never ending) Birthday/All holiday “wish list” is full ;)!

Taylor and Brian Shanfeld 9/21/2021
Matthew Katzman Avatar

We worked with Erin at the Diamond Reserve for both the engagement ring and wedding bands. What a spectacular experience. If you need a custom ring in Denver and high quality diamonds, look no further than the Diamond Reserve. Erin showed great attention to detail when helping customize our rings and was super transparent and respectful of our budget. When we approached with a unique and customized request for a wedding band, the team at the Diamond Reserve was eager to make it happen! Erin was responsive, kind and helped us enjoy this unique experience. We loved working with them and would be happy to recommend to absolutely anyone.

Matthew Katzman 9/20/2021
Libby Paplow Avatar

My fiance worked with Kayleigh to design my engagement ring in April and I love it! Naturally we came back to Diamond Reserve to design our wedding bands for our upcoming wedding and Erin was equally great to work with. They are quick to get back to us and very easy to work with. We highly recommend them!

Libby Paplow 8/31/2021
Joshua Wallace Avatar

Kaeleigh and Erin are both really easy to work with. They made the process of getting both the engagement ring and our wedding bands really easy. I appreciated the option to do virtual sessions at first to talk about what we were looking for and learn about the next steps. Our custom engagement ring turned out amazingly and I can't wait to get our wedding bands!

Joshua Wallace 8/31/2021
Reza Zahedi Avatar

Kaeleigh and the Diamond Reserve were recommended to me by a friend when I was looking for an engagement ring and the referral came with high praise which was well deserved. She is honest, experienced, knowledgeable, and loves her job. We went back for our wedding rings and will continue to reach out to her if we need more jewelry in the future. I highly recommend them!

Reza Zahedi 8/19/2021
Ashley Kmon Avatar

There aren’t enough good things to say about the Diamond Reserve! My fiancé and I had SO much fun designing our wedding bands with Erin- we felt like two kids in a candy store working with her! She was so much fun, showed us hundreds of ideas for inspiration, and ultimately helped us craft the exact rings we were dreaming of. The cherry creek office is beautiful, too! We are SO obsessed with our rings and cannot wait to work with Erin again in the future for more pieces!

Ashley Kmon 8/02/2021
Molly Goble Avatar

Erin with the Diamond Reserve is amazing and made the process of buying our wedding bands and my engagement ring so much fun! My ring is absolutely gorgeous and so special with the custom touches my fiance was able to choose. We were a little lost when we first starting looking at rings. Erin made sure it was a ring that I would love as well as something that my finace was able to customize. Could not be happier with our rings and experience.

Molly Goble 7/28/2021
Olivia Moore Avatar

I had a great time working with the team on my rings. Everyone in the office is so friendly. They created exactly what I wanted. There was a great selection of stones to choose from. I hope to use them in the future for any other jewelry needs.

Olivia Moore 7/26/2021
Kelly Bolden Avatar

Can't say enough great things about The Diamond Reserve in cherry creek. Erin was SO knowledgeable and helpful throughout our entire experience of choosing and designing our rings. We looked at quite a few diamond ring suppliers in Denver and they were BY FAR the most impressive. Not only are their diamonds incredible and unique, but their customer service was amazing. Erin was so attentive to us from the moment we first met her until long after we received our rings - which made the whole experience easy, fun and stress-free.

Highly recommend them to anyone looking for diamond rings, no matter what your experience level is with the diamond-shopping process. We're so happy with our rings and I can't wait to not-so-subtly 'hint' to my husband to go back and work with them again in a few years 😉

Kelly Bolden 7/19/2021
Kelly Florence Avatar

Can't say enough great things about The Diamond Reserve in cherry creek. Erin was SO knowledgeable and helpful throughout our entire experience of choosing and designing our rings. We looked at quite a few diamond ring suppliers in Denver and they were BY FAR the most impressive. Not only are their diamonds incredible and unique, but their customer service was amazing. Erin was so attentive to us from the moment we first met her until long after we received our rings - which made the whole experience easy, fun and stress-free.

Highly recommend them to anyone looking for diamond rings, no matter what your experience level is with the diamond-shopping process. We're so happy with our rings and I can't wait to not-so-subtly 'hint' to my husband to go back and work with them again in a few years 😉

Kelly Florence 7/19/2021
Marcus Fisher Avatar

I got my fiance's engagement ring and wedding band here. Erin was great to work with and was always quick to respond and follow up with me. The ring renderings are incredibly helpful and really make you feel comfortable with the design before moving forward with the actual creation.

Marcus Fisher 7/16/2021
Katy Greene Avatar

Kaeleigh and her team were awesome! She helped us take old family heirlooms and transform them into treasures that will be with us forever. I liked her work on my engagement ring so much that I had her redo an old cocktail ring that was my grandmothers. Previously I had moved it more in the last 15 years than I had worn it, now it is something I wear weekly! She’s got a great sense of style, makes the process simple, streamlined, and low pressure. Would definitely recommend to a friend.

Katy Greene 7/09/2021
Craig Lizotte Avatar

Kaeleigh was awesome to work with. She helped guide me through not only the engagement ring process but also our wedding bands. Her communication was always prompt. Best of all the rings that she and her team put together are amazing.

Craig Lizotte 7/09/2021
Brett Finkelstein Avatar

Kaeleigh and the team are exceptional! Have worked with them for both an engagement ring and wedding bands. They make the experience fun and easy! Would not go anywhere else!

Brett Finkelstein 7/07/2021
Shelby Behr Avatar

We had a great experience at The Diamond Reserve! My fiancé got my engagement ring made here, which I absolutely love. We came back to pick out our wedding bands as well and everyone was super nice and helpful. Highly recommend!

Shelby Behr 6/28/2021
Allison Duni Avatar

I highly recommend working with The Diamond Reserve. Kaeleigh’s expertise is exemplary! She walked us through the whole process from ring design to achieving the engagement ring of my dreams! The process was transparent, efficient, and professional. I would definitely seek out their services for all my future jewelry and Diamond needs!

Allison Duni 6/23/2021
Shelly Anderson Avatar

Kaeleigh and the team at the Diamond Reserve were SO great to work with! We came in to look at engagement rings and she was so helpful not only teaching us about all of our diamond options, but guiding us and really hearing what we wanted for our vision. The ring is PERFECT and I get compliments on it almost daily. We would come in again to pick out our weddings bands and found ourselves just chatting for about two hours. We will have to come back in for more diamonds and more chat!

Shelly Anderson 6/16/2021
Luke Mollnow Avatar

Excellent group that makes your vision of the ring custom here local in Denver. The ring is premium quality and we could not be more happy with the engagement ring. We are going back to get the wedding bands from The Diamond Reserve as well.

Luke Mollnow 5/22/2021
Julia Sobek Avatar

The diamond reserve is where everyone should go for jewelry and custom engagement rings! My fiancé worked with Erin when designing my GORGEOUS engagement ring, better than anything I could have expected. When working with Erin on a personal jewelry piece of mine and wedding bands, she is responsive, experienced, and just a pleasure to be around and consult with. Many times I’ve asked her what she thinks is best when I’m wavering and her suggestions are always spot on. Couldn’t have asked for a better engagement and wedding band experience!

Julia Sobek 5/16/2021
Sarah Hensley Avatar

Working with Kaeleigh at the Diamond reserve was such an amazing experience. She is super personable and friendly. We made both my wedding bands, my engagement ring, and my fiancé’s wedding band here. All of our rings were beautiful and quality work! We trusted them with our family heirloom diamonds and the setting they suggested turned out beautiful. I will always recommend them to family and friends!

Sarah Hensley 5/14/2021
Alexandra Hoefler Avatar

I highly recommend Erin from The Diamond Reserve. She took a family heirloom that was in a bad setting and helped me create it into my dream engagement ring. There was no pressure at my first appointment to purchase anything; it was all educational. Erin went through the process of describing metals, settings and how to create the ring I wanted. At my second appointment I pulled the trigger and decided on what I wanted. It was really difficult deciding a 4 vs. 6 prong setting, and Erin showed me how each would look to help make my decision. I was sent a 3D viewing of the ring to approve and or make any changes I felt necessary, and once approved my ring was made. I had been to several other jewelry stores looking at similar settings, however none of those pre-made settings would have fit my diamond as beautifully as this custom creation. Also, many other jewelers would not work with a diamond that was not purchased from their store. The Diamond Reserve made the entire process of engagement ring shopping easy, affordable, and even fun. I am excited in the future to continue making new custom pieces out of the heirloom jewelry I have, and just want any budget friendly bride to know that you can have a custom ring for a very affordable price.

Alexandra Hoefler 5/07/2021
Claire Tabolt Avatar

Obsessed with the Diamond Reserve! After two friends highly recommended her, I came to Kaeleigh with a unique sizing problem on my engagement ring. She and her team worked with me for months to get the perfect, custom ring. I couldn't be happier. My fiance and I both got our wedding bands from here after the incredible job they did on my engagement ring. Their customer service and stunning jewelry will have us coming back again and again...or until my fiance cuts me off...

Claire Tabolt 5/04/2021
Brooke Ledsworth Avatar

My fiancé bought my engagement ring from the diamond reserve and I am SO HAPPY that he did!! First of all, my engagement ring is more gorgeous than I ever could have imagined! Secondly, it made me so happy hearing about how wonderful his experience was working with Kaeleigh, the owner, when designing and purchasing my ring. He said that she made the whole process as easy and enjoyable as can be, which is always a relief. I had the pleasure of working with her myself when we went back to pick out our wedding bands and she exudes professionalism and passion for what she does, and, most importantly, her diamonds are BOMB!!!!! I LOVE the diamond reserve and will use this team for all of my jewelry needs for life!

Brooke Ledsworth 4/30/2021
Demetrius C Avatar

Without a doubt, the best experience you could possibly get when searching and building the perfect wedding ring. Erin and her team are absolutely stellar to work with and make you feel at ease throughout the process. They have all these 5 star reviews for a reason.

Demetrius C 4/16/2021
Breanne Bitar Avatar

About a year ago, my fiance asked if I wanted to go try on wedding rings. He mentioned this place. I can honestly say, not only is their office SO cute.. they are the friendliest, helpful most trustful ladies, ever! I have never once felt like I was being taken advantage of (or my soon to be husband) and we will. continue to always recommend and support them even after the wedding. Don't regret them! Trust your significant other here!!! These ladies will seriously give them the best price without ever trying to rip them off... even if they have no idea whats going on 🙂

Breanne Bitar 4/15/2021
Jade Darrough Avatar

Best jeweler in Denver!
The Diamond Reserve made our dream, custom engagement ring come to life! It was no question that we'd create our wedding bands with them as well. They are kind, professional and incredibly talented. Look no further 😊

Jade Darrough 4/13/2021