Reviews

Bekah Pastor Avatar

My (now) fiancé and I went to look at engagement rings at Shane Co. a few weeks before getting engaged. They told him it would take a few weeks to get the ring, so he searched elsewhere and discovered The Diamond Reserve. They were so awesome and able to help in a pinch! We are working with them on our wedding bands and I was so thrilled after meeting the team in person. They’re great to work with, very honest and their products are truly spectacular!

Bekah Pastor 7/27/2022
Reba Ruckel Avatar

My (now) fiancé and I went to look at engagement rings at Shane Co. a few weeks before getting engaged. They told him it would take a few weeks to get the ring, so he searched elsewhere and discovered The Diamond Reserve. They were so awesome and able to help in a pinch! We are working with them on our wedding bands and I was so thrilled after meeting the team in person. They’re great to work with, very honest and their products are truly spectacular!

Reba Ruckel 7/27/2022
Becky Fox Avatar

The Diamond Reserve has been awesome to work with. From working with my fiance in 2019 to get a somewhat last minute engagement ring of my dreams made, to helping make me a custom wedding band for the wedding finally happening in 2022 that matches my engagement ring, they have been nothing but fantastic. It is always such a fun and stress free environment and we have such a good time every time that we go there. I will get jewelry made here for years to come and have and will continue to recommend them to people!

Becky Fox 7/26/2022
Stefanie Raccuglia Avatar

Erin is amazing at what she does! She and my fiance designed my engagement ring (which is gorgeous), and then together we designed my 2 wedding bands for a look that is truly unique and stunning! She has a beautiful selection of men's wedding bands as well, and communicates honestly about the materials and value. The quality of her work and diamonds is fantastic, her knowledge is extensive and working with her is fun, easy, enjoyable and comforting! I highly recommend the Diamond Reserve!

Stefanie Raccuglia 7/17/2022
Sam Avatar

Erin is the best! We loved working w/ The Diamond Reserve. Made ring shopping so easy and fun. Was such a success with the engagement ring we went back and used them for the wedding band too. Thank you guys!!

Sam 7/12/2022
Brittany Whittaker Avatar

Erin is always so easy to work with! She makes your vision come to life. My fiancé made my custom engagement ring with Erin and it turned out better than I could even imagine. We are now working with Erin to make our custom wedding bands and we cannot wait to see how they turn out! Highly recommend using The Diamond Reserve for all of your custom jewelry needs.

Brittany Whittaker 7/08/2022
devora magner Avatar

Erin is beyond amazing, sweet and kind! She helped my fiance find the perfect ring that I am absolutely in love with and helped me pick the perfect wedding band. Erin is knowledgeable and definitely knows what she's doing. Her eye for detail is incredible! I will be doing a few more things in the future with the Diamond Reserve!

devora magner 7/01/2022
Christen Daddario Avatar

We visited two other jewelry stores before meeting Erin at Diamond Reserve. Erin took the time to explain all we needed to know about picking and purchasing an engagement ring. She is so patient, helpful and willing to answer all my questions. She has gone above and beyond and created a beautiful engagement ring. I also went back to Erin to help create a necklace for my mom, which she loves! Would highly recommend Erin and The Diamond Reserve!

Christen Daddario 5/23/2022
Makayla Welham Avatar

My fiance took me to the diamond reserve to look at diamonds and give him an idea of some rings I would like. After leaving the diamond reserve that day I felt 100% comfortable letting him, with Kaeleighs help design my ring! We are going back for our wedding bands as well and I know we will definitely trust her for other jewelry for years to come. I cannot say enough great things about the diamond reserve.

Makayla Welham 5/05/2022
Kayla Russell Avatar

We can’t say enough about Kaeleigh and Erin, and our experience at The Diamond Reserve. They are amazing in helping you design the ring of your dreams… large or small, ornate or simple. They have been great to work with- they have educated us about diamonds and advised us based on their expertise. In the end we saved money in comparison to online retailers and had exactly what we wanted from someone we trust! I couldn’t ask for more!
I absolutely love my engagement ring (it is stunning :))and we’ve been shopping for wedding rings with them as well. We were in Denver traveling when we first met with them and have been so happy with them that we have been back twice now to the showroom and worked with them virtually online.
We wouldn’t use anyone else!

Kayla Russell 4/15/2022
Natalie Peikoff Avatar

I absolutely love the team at The Diamond Reserve! I chatted with Kaeleigh initially and she was so thorough in her explanation of all things diamonds - and then my fiance worked with her to make my dream ring. We just ordered our wedding bands with Erin and she was equally as thorough and wonderful in her help and guidance. We can't say enough great things about The Diamond Reserve - look no further for amazing, talented, knowledgeable, trustworthy jewelers!!

Natalie Peikoff 4/04/2022
Joyce Mathew Avatar

We had an excellent experience at The Diamond Reserve. Erin worked with my fiancé and I to design a unique and sentimental engagement ring using a family heirloom. My ring is absolutely beautiful and it is a joy to wear every day. I especially loved how she and her designers were able to refresh the band and incorporate it so perfectly with the diamond we selected. She was so helpful in answering our questions and guiding us through the entire diamond selection process. Thank you for the incredible ring!

Joyce Mathew 3/12/2022
Faith Wilwerding Avatar

My fiancé worked with the Diamond Reserve to create the perfect engagement ring for me. I absolutely love it and the team at the Diamond Reserve did an amazing job of guiding him through a process that was unfamiliar. We recently went back to pick out our wedding bands and had an equally wonderful experience! We worked with Erin and she made the process so easy and fun. We were able to try on a ton of different styles in a no pressure environment. Erin gave great, balanced advice that helped us pick out the perfect bands!

Faith Wilwerding 3/07/2022
Devin McLean Avatar

Erin and the team at Diamond Reserve have been great from the start of the process. Shopping for the perfect engagement ring is stressful, but not here! There is no pressure, no frills, just help picking the right ring for your significant other. They really listen to what YOU want. We enjoyed the experience so much that we are back for our wedding bands! Thank you!

Devin McLean 3/07/2022
Stephen Manning Avatar

Erin and her staff are absolutely a joy to work with. They made the diamond selection process a fun adventure. Erin educated us on the all relevant details, in a pressure-free environment, and took our feedback to heart. My fiance's tastes and preferences were taken into consideration and Erin found us the best possible diamond at an incredible fair price point. We will look back on this process with no stress and plenty of smiles.

Stephen Manning 3/03/2022
Marisa Paukovich Avatar

We have had the most incredible experience working with The Diamond Reserve! My fiancé worked with Erin to create the perfect engagement ring for me. He raved about the knowledge he gained and how comfortable he felt during this process. We are now working with Erin to design our dream wedding bands and have again had a phenomenal experience. We both agree Erin is one of the nicest, friendliest people we have ever met, and recommend The Diamond Reserve to all our friends who are thinking of getting engaged.

Marisa Paukovich 3/02/2022
Afra Ashraf Avatar

Working with Erin and her team at the Diamond Reserve was a great experience. My fiancé and I were unsure of what we wanted when we came in to get our wedding bands, and Erin made multiple accommodations to make sure that we got our dream rings and at a reasonable price point as well. Aside from that, they’re also just great, friendly people to work with. Very trustworthy. I would highly recommend anyone that is getting married to go to the Diamond Reserve if you want great service, reasonable price points and beautiful rings!

Afra Ashraf 3/01/2022
Penny Eckel Avatar

Kaeleigh did an amazing job helping us customize an engagement ring and wedding band. She made us feel comfortable during the process and guided us in our decision making, without being pushy. We loved working with her! We had to move our wedding date up a bit and needed the wedding band in a rush. She and her team created a render, made the ring, and shipped it to us in a rush, without any compromise on quality.

Penny Eckel 2/28/2022
Mani Chandy Avatar

Erin was an absolutely dream to work with! I cannot recommend the Diamond Reserve strongly enough. From the moment my partner and I walked into their inviting office Erin was warm, friendly, knowledgeable, and completely put us both at ease. We knew little about diamonds or engagement rings, but felt confident with Erin holding our hands through the entire process. We met with her several times and ended up with a custom setting that exceeded our expectations and was far more lovely and unique than anything we could have hoped for if we had gone through a large online store. I highly recommend Erin and her team!

Mani Chandy 2/23/2022
Natalie Fochtman Avatar

We loved working with Erin at the Diamond Reserve! Erin helped my fiance with the perfect engagement ring for me and now we are working with her again for our bands. She just makes everything so simple and straight forward which was perfect not knowing anything about the jewelry industry. We can't recommend Erin and The Diamond Reserve enough and are looking forward to working with them again in the future!

Natalie Fochtman 2/22/2022
E Harden Avatar

First off, we did our research and went to a few shops around town, but once we walked in to the Diamond Reserve we knew we found the right spot. Erin and her team were both wonderfully nice and super knowledgeable. We actually enjoyed chatting, planning and designing and didn't feel as if we were being upsold or even sold the entire time. It was such a collaborative process that the engagement ring we picked out was amazing, top quality and some of the lower prices in town. My fiance and I enjoyed it so much we went back from wedding bands and this will be our spot moving forward.

E Harden 2/18/2022
Will Wallesen Avatar

I had a great experience working with Erin and The Diamond Reserve. I was able to tell Erin what I wanted and what I knew my fiance would like and she helped to create the perfect engagement ring. We're now working on our wedding bands and are having the same helpful, professional experience.

Will Wallesen 2/17/2022
Kaylee Caldwell Avatar

I can't express how impressed we are with The Diamond Reserve! My fiance worked with Erin to create the engagement ring of my dreams, and I had absolutely NO idea! Now, we are working with Erin on our wedding bands, and have had a great experience. She is so fun to work with, answers all your questions, and ensures that you're getting exactly what you want. We can't recommend her and The Diamond Reserve enough!

Kaylee Caldwell 2/09/2022
Morgan Harksen Avatar

I cannot recommend The Diamond Reserve enough! We loved working with Kaeleigh. She made picking out wedding bands an exciting and easy experience. Not only that, but she helped my fiancé guess my ring size perfectly based on looking at a photo - amazing!! The Diamond Reserve has a fun and comfortable atmosphere too, making it that much easier to find the perfect rings. We couldn't be happier with the whole experience and adore the rings we picked.

Morgan Harksen 1/26/2022
Maggie Riedel Avatar

We love The Diamond Reserve! My fiancé and I were so pleased with Erin. She made picking out engagement bands so easy and stress free. She really took the time to understand exactly what we wanted and helped create it for us. We will forever be grateful to The Diamond Reserve for making us the perfect wedding bands.
Maggie & Jon

Maggie Riedel 1/25/2022
Payton Cain Avatar

I loved my experience with the Diamond Reserve! The staff is very friendly and knowledgeable. I originally got an engagement ring through the Diamond Reserve and I was so satisfied with the way they placed my grandmother's diamond that we are now back to get wedding bands! I would highly recommend the Diamond Reserve!

Payton Cain 1/15/2022
Rebecca Kling Avatar

My Fiancé and I worked with The Diamond Reserve for both my engagement ring and our wedding bands. They are so knowledgeable, kind, and very patient. Erin made the wedding band buying process so easy and was willing to meet with me multiple times while I was making my decision. We will definitely be working with them again in the future!

Rebecca Kling 12/21/2021
Marc Blumenthal Avatar

One of the most significant purchases of our life. The journey to design the symbol of our union brought us to Kaeleigh and Erin at The Diamond Reserve. We are so grateful for the knowledge, expertise, and care delivered by this company. Everything from quality, communication, and pricing was above and beyond any other company we interacted with while engagement ring shopping. We will be using The Diamond Reserve again and have been spreading the word to our family and friends. What an exemplary business here in Denver Colorado.

Marc Blumenthal 12/14/2021
Abbey Drevline Avatar

Timeless, elegant, and personable. The Diamond Reserve took my lifetime vision of my engagement ring and turned my dream into a reality. Not a day goes by that I don’t look at my ring and admire every detail that was put into it. I also had such a great experience with Erin and picking out our wedding bands!! The whole team is amazing and I highly recommended!

Abbey Drevline 11/23/2021
Sarah Maslo Avatar

Working with the Diamond Reserve for both my engagement ring and wedding band was a fantastic decision. I wanted a small, simple, lab-grown gemstone ring and they were so respectful of that wish. They designed a set that really matches my personality; I love both my engagement ring and wedding band. Their work is beautiful, and I'd absolutely recommend them to anyone searching for an engagement ring.

Sarah Maslo 11/21/2021