Reviews

Joseph Kmetz Avatar

Kaeleigh and Erin were great to work with and helped me pick out the PERFECT diamond engagement ring for my fiancee. They are ethical and gave me a fair deal on a beautiful ring. I recommend the Diamond Reserve without reservation. Please support this local business and book an appointment ASAP.

Joseph Kmetz 1/20/2019
David Crump Avatar

Working with Kaeleigh at the Diamond Reserve was great! I was able to give her an idea of what I was looking for and we ended up creating a beautiful engagement ring in a matter of weeks, which gets compliments all the time. My fiance' and I even went back for our wedding bands, and again had a wonderful experience.

David Crump 1/17/2019
Joseph Kmetz Avatar

Kaeleigh and Erin were great to work with and helped me pick out the PERFECT diamond engagement ring for my fiancee. They are of the highest ethical caliber, and Kaeleigh gave me a fair deal on a beautiful ring. I recommend the Diamond Reserve without reservation. Please support this local business and book an appointment ASAP.

Joseph Kmetz 12/22/2018
Rosa Eiler Avatar

Look no further!! We had the most amazing experience at the Diamond Reserve and it’s safe to say that everyone in my life now knows who they are! 😊



Kaeleigh and Erin took the time to guide us through their entire process, carefully explaining each and every step to ensure we were educated and moreover, comfortable and happy with our purchase/decision. 



Thank you both so much for everything!! The ring is PERFECT!!


You are amazing, down to earth people with such an incredible business!

Rosa Eiler 12/06/2018
Joseph Mann Avatar

What an amazing experience! I cannot say enough about the Diamond Reserve and just how incredible they've been on every level.

From the moment we walked in, we knew it was a wonderful fit. Both Kaeleigh and Erin carefully notated exactly what we desired and truly made everything come to life. They were kind, honest and what really stuck out to us, was their desire for us to leave happy.

Not only did we feel great about our purchase, but we both recognized that this was the start of a great relationship.

Customer service is quite hard to come by, but when you find someone who really cares and takes pride in their work, you'll never go anywhere else!

#foreverstartshere

Joseph Mann 12/04/2018
Nathan Greathouse Avatar

Kaeleigh and Erin were awesome to work with both for designing an engagement ring and later for my wife’s wedding band! I was looking for a place that would help me re-use my grandmother’s diamond in a simple yet elegant ring. I brought in a couple of pictures and they knew exactly what was needed. They were prompt in communication and did an excellent job.

Nathan Greathouse 11/05/2018
Nathan Greathouse Avatar

Kaeleigh and Erin were awesome to work with both for designing an engagement ring and later for my wife’s wedding band! I was looking for a place that would help me re-use my grandmother’s diamond in a simple yet elegant ring. I brought in a couple of pictures and they knew exactly what was needed. They were prompt in communication and did an excellent job.

Nathan Greathouse 11/05/2018
Amanda Carlson Avatar

Late August my fiancé surprised me with a stunning engagement ring. After the shock wore off, he told me how he worked with Kaeleigh at The Diamond Reserve in Cherry Creek to get the ring custom made with his grandmother's diamond as the center piece. I absolutely love it!

I'm embarrassed to admit that I originally looked for my wedding band at some generic retail stores where they offered minimal choices and couldn't match my engagement ring well. I soon realized it would be in my best interest to continue working with The Diamond Reserve. They responded very quickly to my email and were flexible to accommodate my schedule to make an appointment with them. I worked with Erin who ensured the narrow width and sharp edge of my engagement band would perfectly match my wedding band. I could not be happier.

Amanda Carlson 11/03/2018
Amanda Greathouse Avatar

Late August my fiancé surprised me with a stunning engagement ring. After the shock wore off, he told me how he worked with Kaeleigh at The Diamond Reserve in Cherry Creek to get the ring custom made with his grandmother's diamond as the center piece. I absolutely love it!

I'm embarrassed to admit that I originally looked for my wedding band at some generic retail stores where they offered minimal choices and couldn't match my engagement ring well. I soon realized it would be in my best interest to continue working with The Diamond Reserve. They responded very quickly to my email and were flexible to accommodate my schedule to make an appointment with them. I worked with Erin who ensured the narrow width and sharp edge of my engagement band would perfectly match my wedding band. I could not be happier. 5 out of 5!!

Amanda Greathouse 11/03/2018
Jason MacPherson Avatar

Such an amazing experience creating the perfect ring for my fiance! Kaeleigh does a fantastic job and is super easy to work with. I thought this was going to be a long and difficult process but she made me feel so comfortable and designed the most amazing ring for me to propose with. Truly incredible!

Jason MacPherson 10/24/2018
Jason MacPherson Avatar

Kaeleigh does an amazing job! She made this experience so easy for me and was super helpful in designing the perfect ring. Great experience overall, I would highly recommend going to see her.

Jason MacPherson 10/24/2018
Ryan Monroe Avatar

Kaeleigh was extremely easy to work with and a true expert at her craft. She made sure that everything was within the budget I gave her, and quickly tracked down exactly what I was looking for albeit rare. I highly recommend her.

Ryan Monroe 10/01/2018
Ryan Monroe Avatar

Kaeleigh was extremely easy to work with and a true expert at her craft. She made sure that everything was within the budget I gave her, and quickly tracked down exactly what I was looking for albeit rare. I highly recommend her.

Ryan Monroe 10/01/2018
Carl Kline Avatar

Thank you Kaeleigh and Erin for helping me with one of the most important decisions I have ever made! The ring was everything she wanted, and I couldn’t be happier with how everything turned out.

Carl Kline 9/28/2018
Ashley Nichol Avatar

Kaeleigh was wonderful to work with! My fiancé and I initially met with her together to get some ideas of what I liked. She immediately made us feel comfortable with the whole process, and we never felt like she was trying to sell us anything.

My fiancé went back several months later to design my ring with her, and I couldn’t be happier with it. It is exactly what I wanted, and even came in under budget!

We highly recommend and will most definitely be using The Diamond Reserve again in the future!

Ashley Nichol 9/28/2018
Lauren Cowher Avatar

Kaeleigh and Erin are a dream team - warm and fun demeanors, incredibly knowledgeable about their craft, honest in their opinions, reliable and lightning fast to boot. My fiancé worked with them to create my custom engagement ring and I loved it so much that I decided to get my wedding band designed with them, too. We incorporated diamonds from a very special earring my late mom gave me into both rings, and Kaeleigh has taken great care in doing so - giving me two pieces that will always carry very deep sentimental value. The second I walked into their office, they felt like old friends. I imagine it's hard to find this kind of service elsewhere in Denver. I recommend them fully!

Lauren Cowher 9/18/2018
David Ziegler Avatar

Found the perfect diamond quicker then anyone in town. My fiancé can’t say enough about her ring.

David Ziegler 9/12/2018
Julia DuVal Avatar

Kaeleigh and her team make this process amazing. She has the connections to find you the diamond you want, the taste to provide amazing feedback towards your design...and she's just fun to work with. Don't bother going anywhere else!

Julia DuVal 9/11/2018
Onesimo Ledezma Avatar

I would like thank Kaeleigh for designing the perfect engagement ring!!! I had been looking for a couple of months but could not find the one that I liked, until I found The Diamond Reserve. Kaeleigh was very helpful and worked with me to design a beautiful ring.

Onesimo Ledezma 9/11/2018
Martha Silva Avatar

Kaeleigh was extremely helpful with resizing my engagement ring. It look less than a week! Thanks for all of your help!

Martha Silva 9/11/2018
Hannah Weyhrauch Avatar

There is nothing more special than seeing the love of your life get down on one knee and asked to spend forever with you. But there is nothing quite like an experienced designer with beautiful taste to make that memory last forever on your finger. I have had the most amazing experience working with Kaeleigh and her team at the Diamond Reserve. Their attention to detail and their communication is top-of-the-line. Thank you so much for everything you I have done for us I will recommend you to everyone in the future.

Hannah Weyhrauch 9/11/2018
Lauren Pierpoint Avatar

Kaeleigh was wonderful to work with. She worked to get us the perfect engagement ring and the perfect wedding rings!

Lauren Pierpoint 9/07/2018
Athena Brownson Avatar

The Diamond Reserve truly is the best jeweler I have worked with in Denver. Kaeleigh has assisted me with designing and creating several custom pieces, all of which exceeded my expectations. Their communication is top notch and quality is impeccable. I would highly recommend using them for all your diamond and jewelry needs.

Athena Brownson 9/01/2018
Ben Wiechman Avatar

The Diamond reserve was great! Kaleigh was super approachable, put my mind at ease with the whole process, and worked within my budget. Highly recommend going with the Diamond Reserve!

Ben Wiechman 8/18/2018
Mike Hosted Avatar

This was a great experience! Kaeleigh and her staff are very helpful, have great ideas, and very thorough in the process and timing! I highly recommend The Diamond Reserve!

Mike Hosted 8/09/2018
Victoria Chu Avatar

My fiancé had an idea of what I wanted, but just wanted to be sure, so we set up our appointment together. His work schedule is crazy, and Kaeleigh was able to work around it! We talked about the 4C's, and she was able to find the PERFECT diamond for me. She listens to you, and gives you everything you could possibly want and more. (She's a "dream maker!") She was also able to finish the ring to fit in line with my fiancé's timeline, and kept everything an amazing secret, even though I was partially involved! I'm definitely super hard to surprise. Kaeleigh is an absolute pleasure to work with, it's like basically talking to a girl friend you've known for forever! You can't go wrong working with The Diamond Reserve!

Victoria Chu 8/08/2018
T.d. Gonzales Avatar

This is the place I should have started at.

Kaeleigh provides the best customer service out there. The entire shopping experience at the Diamond Reserve was like nothing I experienced anywhere else. Kaeleigh was incredibly respectful and helpful as she walked me through the process of picking out a ring my fiance loves.

T.d. Gonzales 8/02/2018
Brendan Payne Avatar

My fiance loves her ring. Kaeleigh is outstanding. She easily explains everything a buyer needs to know about diamonds and provides high quality options.

Brendan Payne 7/31/2018
Danielle Lowe Avatar

We had a great experience at The Diamond Reserve when picking out my engagement ring. We went in thinking that I would have Kaeleigh design something for me but ended up picking a ring that she had previously designed. We had a few meetings and once we were ready she explained how to buy a diamond and laid out my loose diamond choices. We then compared the loose ones but I fell in love with the one she had designed (Double Halo!). The center stone was a match to what I wanted in the 4 Cs and the price was on point for the budget. When comparing The Diamond Reserve with other options (we shopped around for a while), they are hands down the best out there in products, pricing, and service. They have a fun office and a no pressure environment. They are creative and are passionate with the jewelry they have designed. We also just purchased my finance’s wedding band and will use them for future wants.

Danielle Lowe 7/27/2018
Kasey Beal Avatar

Amazing and personal customer service and my fiancee's wedding ring is as beautiful as it gets. She absolutely loves it and it stands out in a crowd. This is a no pressure sales experience and Kaeleigh knew exactly which questions to ask to ensure we were choosing the correct size and setting. You wont be disappointed with The Diamond Reserve!

Kasey Beal 7/11/2018